Leave your minpaku property management to us
Free Online ConsultationWhy Do Owners End Up Dissatisfied with Property Management Companies?
Many property owners find themselves frustrated with their property management company, wondering whether they should cancel first and then search for a replacement, or run both processes in parallel. The longer dissatisfaction with a management company goes unaddressed, the more revenue opportunities are lost—and the more it can hurt your property’s reputation. This article breaks down the common causes of dissatisfaction and offers concrete guidance on the best timing and approach for canceling and switching providers.
To cut to the chase: in most cases, running both processes in parallel is the right answer. That said, depending on your contract terms and the state of your property, canceling first may sometimes be the better move. Let’s look at the criteria for making this decision, along with real-world trouble scenarios you’re likely to encounter.
5 Common Reasons Owners Become Dissatisfied with Property Management Companies
Dissatisfaction with management companies tends to follow a few typical patterns. Accurately identifying which category your frustration falls into is the first step toward deciding what to do next. If you act emotionally without a clear diagnosis, you risk running into the exact same problems with your next provider.
Occupancy Rates and Revenue Fall Far Short of Expectations
It’s not uncommon for owners to be told at contract signing that they can expect monthly revenue of around ¥300,000, only to see actual figures hovering around ¥150,000. The simulations management companies present are typically based on best-case scenarios, and if pricing adjustments and listing optimization are neglected, occupancy rates can fall below 50%. As a general benchmark, if your occupancy rate has stayed under 60% for three months or more relative to your property’s location and grade, there’s a strong chance something is wrong with the operational management.
Poor Quality Guest Communication
Delayed check-in instructions, inquiry responses that take hours to arrive, and slow reactions to problems all directly impact your review scores. On Airbnb, falling below a 4.5 overall rating means losing Superhost status and dropping in search rankings—which in turn affects booking volume. The moment you see two or more guest reviews mentioning “slow response,” you should start questioning your management company’s operational structure.
Lack of Transparency in Reporting and Communication
A lack of monthly reports, missing notifications when cleaning is complete, or unclear expense breakdowns are all serious red flags. For example, if ¥15,000 a month is being charged for “supplies” with no itemized details of what was actually purchased, the possibility of fraudulent billing can’t be ruled out. If requests for disclosure only get vague answers, rebuilding trust becomes extremely difficult.
Poor Cleaning and Maintenance Quality
Declining cleaning quality has the most direct impact on guest satisfaction. If hair left behind, mold in bathrooms, or stained linens drag your “cleanliness” category rating below 4.0, your competitiveness on the platform drops sharply. Even if a single cleaning costs only ¥3,000–5,000, poor quality control can end up costing you many times that amount in lost revenue.
Gap Between Contract Terms and Actual Service
There are also numerous reports of discrepancies between what’s promised in the contract and what actually happens—such as a contract stating “24-hour support” but phone calls going unanswered late at night, or “photography included” service resulting in unexpected additional charges. These gaps often stem from mismatches between verbal explanations and the written contract. Reviewing the exact wording of your contract and keeping a record of which specific clauses aren’t being honored will provide crucial evidence for your next steps.
Pros and Cons of Canceling First, Then Searching for a New Provider
Let’s first look at the option of canceling your current contract before searching for a new management company. While this approach seems straightforward, it carries the significant risk of leaving your property with a gap in management. If your property generates ¥200,000 in monthly revenue, for instance, even just one month spent selecting and signing with a new company translates to ¥200,000 in lost opportunity.
That said, this approach does have advantages. If your current contract is exclusive (prohibiting the use of other companies simultaneously) and doesn’t impose cancellation penalties, canceling first allows you to compare multiple companies with a clean slate. Additionally, by reclaiming full control of your accounts (such as your Airbnb listing) before handing things over to a new company, you can more easily avoid data-transfer complications.
Steps for Switching Providers While Under Your Current Contract
For most owners, the more practical approach is to keep the current contract active while searching for a new provider in parallel. This eliminates any gap in service, minimizing disruption to your revenue. However, getting the sequence wrong can cause problems, so keep the following steps in mind.
Review the Cancellation Clause in Your Current Contract
The first thing to do is thoroughly review the cancellation clause in your current contract. Whether the required notice period is “one month” or “three months” will completely change how you plan your schedule. If an early termination penalty is specified, calculate what percentage of the remaining management fees that penalty represents, and compare it against the projected revenue improvement from switching providers. For example, even a ¥150,000 penalty could be recouped within three months if switching leads to a ¥50,000 monthly revenue increase.
List and Compare Candidate Companies
List at least three candidate companies and compare their management fee rates, scope of services, track record, and approach to review management. While a revenue-linked fee of 15–20% is fairly standard, actual costs can vary significantly depending on whether cleaning and supply costs are included or billed separately. During consultations, always ask about three key points: target occupancy rates, reporting frequency, and emergency contact procedures. If a company gives vague answers, it’s wise to eliminate them from consideration.
Submit Your Cancellation Notice and Sign the New Contract Simultaneously
Once you’ve chosen a new management company, submit your cancellation notice to your current provider and sign with the new one around the same time. Send your cancellation notice in writing (email is fine, as long as it leaves a record of delivery) and clearly state the cancellation date. Ask your new provider to prepare for a smooth handover—transferring the listing, setting up the cleaning team, and updating key-exchange procedures—so they can begin operations the day after your cancellation takes effect. Ideally, aim to finalize your contract with the new company at least two weeks before your cancellation date.
Confirm the Handover of Accounts and Management Rights
If your Airbnb or Booking.com account is registered in your own name as the owner, switching management companies is relatively simple. However, if the listing was created under the management company’s name, you may not be able to carry over past reviews and booking history. Check who holds the owner rights to the listing, and if it’s not registered under your own name, confirm with your current provider whether and how a transfer is possible. If a transfer isn’t feasible, you’ll need to create a new listing—meaning you should plan your schedule around starting fresh with zero reviews.
Criteria for Deciding Whether to Cancel First
While running both processes in parallel is generally the recommended approach, there are cases where canceling first is the better choice. Specifically, this applies if your management company has caused serious problems with guest handling, is engaging in illegal operations (such as exceeding legally permitted operating days without proper notification), or is suspected of fraudulent expense billing. Since these issues directly threaten your property’s reputation and expose you to legal risk as the owner, you should cancel immediately even without a replacement lined up.
Canceling first is also the safer option if your contract has a strict exclusivity clause that makes even contacting other companies a breach of contract. In such cases, prioritizing risk avoidance is worth accepting a one-to-two-week gap in management. During that gap, you can either block your calendar yourself or handle operations independently on a short-term basis.
Checkpoints to Avoid Mistakes When Switching Providers
Switching management companies isn’t just about signing with someone new. To avoid repeating past mistakes, keep the following points in mind.
Put Your Dissatisfaction into Concrete Terms Before Searching for a New Provider
If you choose a new company based on a vague sense that “the service just wasn’t good,” you’re likely to run into the same problems again. Organize your dissatisfaction around specific facts and figures—for example, “no monthly report for three consecutive months,” “review score dropped from 4.8 to 4.3 over six months,” or “two or more cleaning complaints per month.” Then, ask your prospective new provider exactly how they would address each of these specific issues.
Negotiate Contract Length and Cancellation Terms Upfront
When signing with a new management company, it’s ideal to negotiate a three-month trial period with no cancellation penalty if results aren’t satisfactory. Companies confident in their capabilities tend to be willing to accept such terms. On the other hand, be cautious if a company requires a minimum one-year contract with steep penalties for early termination.
Confirm How Existing Bookings Will Be Handled
How to handle existing future bookings at the time of cancellation is a point that’s easy to overlook. Canceling reservations doesn’t just inconvenience guests—it can also trigger penalties on the platform. Decide in advance whether your current management company will see existing bookings through to completion or whether they’ll be handed over to the new provider, and make sure guests are informed without exception.
Have Questions About Minpaku Management? Talk to Stay Buddy Inc.
Stay Buddy Inc. places a strong emphasis on transparent reporting and maximizing revenue from the owner’s perspective when it comes to minpaku property management. We provide regular monthly reports, clearly defined cleaning quality standards, and a rapid-response system for emergencies—and we also support the listing transfer process when owners are switching from another management company.
If you’re dissatisfied with your current provider, we’ll start by listening to your concerns and then give you an honest assessment of whether improvement is realistic or whether switching would be the better option. We never engage in pushy sales tactics, so feel free to reach out even if you’re just gathering information.
Whether you’re unsure if you should switch from your current provider, or simply don’t know where to start with the switching process, we welcome your questions. Please get in touch through the contact form or by phone via the Stay Buddy Inc. official website.
